Book a call, and before we talk we’ll call your community after hours, the way a family would. Free for operators with 5 or more communities. Book a call →
Guide for assisted living and memory care operators

Senior living mystery shopping: what to test and how to score it

A senior living mystery shop is a call, web inquiry or tour made by someone posing as a family looking for care, to see how a community handles a real prospect. The most useful shops test the moments families actually hit: the first call, the web form, the follow-up and the tour, including nights and weekends.

Book a call

Before we talk, we call your community after hours, the way a family would. Free for operators with 5 or more communities.

Why mystery shop your own communities?

Because your CRM shows what your team logged, not what families went through. Bild & Co. ran more than 250 web and phone mystery shops of senior living communities in 2023, as reported by Senior Housing News. 53% of web inquiries got no response within two hours, 17% of calls were sent straight to voicemail, 13% of calls never got a response at all, and only 19% of shops got a promise of a callback the same day.

What should a senior living mystery shop test?

The first call. Does a person answer, how many rings does it take, and does the team learn who needs care and why now?

Nights and weekends. The same call at 7 PM on a weekday and on a Saturday afternoon. This is where most communities fall down.

The web form. How long until the first response, and is it a call, a text or an automated email?

Follow-up. How many attempts come in the next seven days, and does anyone refer back to what the family said?

The tour. Optional. Did the tour giver know anything about the family before they arrived, and did they set a next step?

How do you score a mystery shop?

Keep the scorecard short enough to compare across communities. Mark each line yes or no, and write down the times.

  1. Reached a live person, and how long it took.
  2. Learned who needs care and why the family is looking now.
  3. Answered with the family’s situation in mind, rather than listing amenities.
  4. Asked for a tour and set a time.
  5. Confirmed the tour by text or email.
  6. Followed up within 24 hours.
  7. Number of follow-ups in the first seven days.

One bad call can be bad luck. The same miss at several communities is a process problem worth fixing. In 14 shops Bild & Co. ran in 2020, reported by Senior Housing News, 43% of sales associates listed amenities without tying them to the caller’s needs.

Should you tell your staff they’ll be shopped?

We suggest telling leadership and the sales team that shops will happen, without saying when. The shop stays realistic, and nobody feels set up. Share the results as coaching, not discipline, and shop again after the team has had time to change.

Can you record mystery shop calls?

Check the law first. Federal law allows a recording when one person on the call agrees, but some states require everyone on the call to agree. The Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press lists California, Delaware, Florida, Illinois, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Montana, New Hampshire, Pennsylvania and Washington, plus Connecticut and Nevada for phone calls. If you’re unsure, take notes and timestamps, or ask your lawyer.

How should you run a shop fairly?

Use a made-up family, never a real person’s name or health details. Use the same script for every community so the results compare. If a shopper books a tour, cancel it promptly so the slot goes to a real family.

How often should you mystery shop?

We suggest once a quarter per community, and again after any change in staffing or in how calls are handled.

Questions about senior living mystery shopping

What is senior living mystery shopping?

Someone poses as a family looking for care and calls, fills out a web form or tours a community, then scores how the team handled it, so operators see what real families experience.

What should a senior living mystery shop test?

The first phone call, calls after hours and on weekends, the web form, follow-up over the next week, and optionally the tour.

Should staff know they are being mystery shopped?

We suggest telling leadership and the sales team that shops will happen, without saying when, and sharing the results as coaching.

Is it legal to record a mystery shop call?

It depends on the state. Some states, including California, Florida, Illinois, Pennsylvania and Washington, require everyone on a call to agree to a recording. Check with a lawyer, or take notes and timestamps instead.

Can we mystery shop our own communities?

Yes. Use someone your staff won't recognize, a made-up family, the scorecard on this page, and the same script for every community so the results compare.

About the authors

Aaron Hayes has spent more than 1,000 hours coaching care home leaders on culture, conflict and staff turnover. Mitchell Miles builds sales systems and led growth at Closers.io. Together they run Lasso Advisory, which helps assisted living and memory care operators turn more inquiries into move-ins.

Meet the team

Related guides

All guides from Lasso Advisory

Sources

Senior Housing News, “Senior Living Operators Level Up Sales to Beat ‘Alarming’ Trends in Conversions,” February 12, 2024, reporting Bild & Co. mystery shops from 2023. Read it.

Senior Housing News, “Bad Senior Living Sales Habits Persist During Covid-19,” June 16, 2020, reporting 14 Bild & Co. mystery shops. Read it.

Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press, Introduction to the Reporter’s Recording Guide. Read it. This page is general information, not legal advice.

Bild & Co. is a senior living sales consultancy.

Find out what your families hear when they call.

Book a call, and before we talk we’ll call your community after hours, free for operators with 5 or more communities.

Book a call